I've been running The Caverns of Thracia for a while in a duet game with my wife.
I also run a discord chat PbP-ish Thracia game.
I just now started a new Thracia game with my wife and 2 (until now) 5e-only players. I'm playtesting my BB\X rules with that group.
+ easy to interpret dungeon details into an overall understanding of the broad situation. Very grokkable
+ most keyed locations are quickly understood without need of interpretation
+ amazing 3-dimensionality and general dungeon layout
+ Factions are good enough and minimal enough to grow naturally through gameplay. They might be better if a smidge more detailed, but they have just the right gaps to fill for me, so far.
+ the whole dungeon is a layered mystery to uncover through exploration and diplomatic play, if the party cares
+ mechanical simplicity. I mostly don't need to look things up or stop to consider what ruling to make
- crammed, dense layout
- some unclear mapping and keying
- poorly organized
- lots of page flipping
- too verbose
- some errors and missed opportunities
Highlight 1: endless ways to get lost, accidentally go deeper, and master the dungeon through using different routes.
Highlight 2: the game is complex, layered, and interesting without a confused GM staring and thinking and referencing other pages all the time. (I had those issues with Maze of the Blue Medusa and Hot Springs Island. You may find them a better fit for you though, of course.)
We're attempting to fix most of the minuses from my review with a rewritten key.
Search
Featured Post
Popular Posts
- Knave Mini-Review, Hacks, Additions, and Other Resources
- Caverns of Thracia session log: February 2, 2019
- Hot Springs Island Mini-review After 6 sessions
- Recommended OSR Books
- Creating a Terse Key (and more) for Caverns of Thracia
- BB/X
- Cleric Spells Are Herbs
- Improve your game with bits of OD&D
- Universal Oldschool RPG Mechanic Toolkit
- Conditions
Topics
mechanics
(24)
GLOG
(9)
session report
(9)
Aid
(8)
class
(8)
setting
(8)
Caverns of Thracia
(7)
Kowloon Planet
(7)
bestiary
(7)
table
(7)
gm
(6)
Resource
(5)
duo
(5)
project
(4)
review
(4)
system
(4)
Fomalhaut
(3)
bbx
(3)
death and dismemberment
(3)
Hot Springs Island
(2)
Knave
(2)
faction
(2)
magic
(2)
npc
(2)
race
(2)
rules
(2)
spells
(2)
theory
(2)
toddler
(2)
200 Words
(1)
HSI
(1)
LotFP
(1)
Secret Santicore
(1)
Stargazer
(1)
adventure
(1)
advice
(1)
character sheet
(1)
cleric
(1)
curse
(1)
disease
(1)
dwarf
(1)
generator
(1)
herbs
(1)
humor
(1)
level
(1)
meta
(1)
random encounters
(1)
treasure
(1)
Related Blogs
-
d100 – What Happens When I Drink The Goo? - Came up with a quick one for all those intensely interesting situations where a Brave or Foolish Player decides they are *really willing* to interact wit...14 hours ago
-
Lair of the Hardcore Dangerous Extradimensional Sorcerer - A high-level dungeon, season to taste. The PCs are nominally supposed to free the prisoner (8) and defeat the Sorcerer (21). The entire dungeon is made of...18 hours ago
-
The Baby in the Briar - By ShanklimbSelf PublishedDomenwoodLevels 2-3 A desperate mother, Brala, approaches the PCs – in a tavern, on the road, etc. When she awoke this morning, h...1 day ago
-
MSF: The Farm (+ Unicorn Meat: the OST) - Joseph Rusling Meeker Spend enough time in the speakeasies and watering holes of the Low Country, and you’ll hear a certain haint-story. It’s never the f...3 days ago
-
Get Busy Writing or Get Busy Dying - I have never read David Gemmell - his oeuvre somehow passed me by. But I have been inspired to do so by a recent article in the *Telegraph* which caught ...4 days ago
-
Terms of Conduct - Independent ships rely on the six great institutions in order to operate, so all captains pledge to an agreed set of terms, sworn by each new crewmember ...6 days ago
-
Why is the Ogre there? - Joe's post on the Quantum Ogre raises an old question about sandbox play: when does moving an encounter around interfere with players' freedom to decide...3 weeks ago
-
Special Attacks when you hit exact AC - Special Attacks Attack an enemy and if you *exactly* hit their AC, you do a special attack! The special attack depends on the type of weapon you're wielding....1 month ago
-
Film Notes: A Selection of Recent(ish) Obscure(ish) Horror Films - Horror has a (well-earned) reputation as a wastebin genre. Here are a few horror-adjacent films, largely without jumpscares, musical stings, and cheap tr...3 months ago
-
Generating the Megastructure - You can pre-generate your structure as part of your prep or you can generate it on the go as you explore it node by node. Both methods are valid but some f...3 months ago
-
My 2025 in Review - Continuing my annual tradition, here are some of my favorite things from the last year. I think this is the first year where I've had to decide not to shou...4 months ago
-
Adventure Game on Cardboard - Here is the game I have been running most recently, that was written on cardboard, in scanned PDF format: https://mraston.itch.io/adventure-game-on-ca...5 months ago
-
Referee Sabotage - It is an old saw that players are bad at executing their plans. Imagine this common scene: the party have some big job that requires planning; perhaps robb...6 months ago
-
Divine Patronage: A Separate System for Party Advancement - In the past, I've written about why parties should have their own character sheet. The party sheet can track reputation, how noisy they are in the dungeon...7 months ago
-
The Reassembulation Will Be Messy - I’m reassembulating wizardthieffighter.com on a different platform, in a different format and style. This reassembulation will be messy. Most links will di...9 months ago
-
On a Happy New Year - We are about to experience the most social upheaval since industrialization. What will that look like in sixty years? Sinless is starting it's third yea...9 months ago
-
-
Under Gallax Hall - Level 4 - Monastery - *"I'm challenging myself to try and write at least 1-3 rooms per day to crank this thing out in like... 3 months, maybe?"* -Me, about 5 years ago. Been ...10 months ago
-
Deep Space & Derelicts: Basic/Xenotech version, an idea for a game - here's a little idea for a game that's been floating around my head for a while. what if early D&D had been based around classic scifi rather than cl...1 year ago
-
Notes on a semi-successful skill system - When I finished my Team Tsathogga campaign back in 2019, one of the things that I noted afterwards was the extent to which fighters had struggled to keep...4 years ago
-
The Worm Ouroboros - The Worm Ouroboros is a proto-fantasy (the in the genre sense) novel by E. R. Eddison, originally published in 1922. It is an amalgam of mythological tradi...5 years ago
-
As Useful As A Pile Of Dicks - Remember STEAL THE EYES OF YASHOGGHUH? Still working on it. The post As Useful As A Pile Of Dicks first appeared on Last Gasp.5 years ago
-
-
Spoils of the Gorgon Coast: The Degenerate Heir - As the kickstarter for the Zinequest Quartet winds down, I find myself in awe of the amount of folks who seem interested in my project; especially given t...6 years ago
-
Prinny Dood! - Prinnies are the souls of the dead who are working off their lives of sin either in the heavenly or infernal realms before they are able to reincarnate...6 years ago
-
Thursdays in Thracia – Part 21 - This is Part 21 of my Thursdays in Thracia B/X Dungeons & Dragons Campaign, an actual play of Jennell Jaquays’ The Caverns of Thracia. For more context, st...6 years ago
-
Elsai Overview - Elsai is a small planet and the only inhabited one orbiting its star. From its spaceport—nothing more than a flattened chunk of rock used by stellar scum—E...7 years ago
-
"The Gardens of Ynn" Referee Control Panels - I recently picked up Emmy Allen's excellent *The Gardens of Ynn*, and I think this will be the next adventure I run. I still have an itch for *Alice in Won...7 years ago
-
Goodbye and Good Luck - Well some of you may have noticed this blog has been down, restricting access for some time. For various reasons I've decided to step away from the OSR...8 years ago
-
Dolmenwood: d30 Encounter Tables - I wrote a few posts with ideas about Dolmenwood encounter tables ages ago. I wasn't really satisfied with those big d100 tables, though, so the topic which...9 years ago
The recent Oerth Journal #31 (e-zine for Greyhawk fans) features several articles on factions which may interest you if you're working on Thracia's factions: https://greyhawkonline.com/oerthjournal/
ReplyDeleteAllan.
Thanks, this is good stuff!
Delete