I've been running The Caverns of Thracia for a while in a duet game with my wife.
I also run a discord chat PbP-ish Thracia game.
I just now started a new Thracia game with my wife and 2 (until now) 5e-only players. I'm playtesting my BB\X rules with that group.
+ easy to interpret dungeon details into an overall understanding of the broad situation. Very grokkable
+ most keyed locations are quickly understood without need of interpretation
+ amazing 3-dimensionality and general dungeon layout
+ Factions are good enough and minimal enough to grow naturally through gameplay. They might be better if a smidge more detailed, but they have just the right gaps to fill for me, so far.
+ the whole dungeon is a layered mystery to uncover through exploration and diplomatic play, if the party cares
+ mechanical simplicity. I mostly don't need to look things up or stop to consider what ruling to make
- crammed, dense layout
- some unclear mapping and keying
- poorly organized
- lots of page flipping
- too verbose
- some errors and missed opportunities
Highlight 1: endless ways to get lost, accidentally go deeper, and master the dungeon through using different routes.
Highlight 2: the game is complex, layered, and interesting without a confused GM staring and thinking and referencing other pages all the time. (I had those issues with Maze of the Blue Medusa and Hot Springs Island. You may find them a better fit for you though, of course.)
We're attempting to fix most of the minuses from my review with a rewritten key.
Search
Featured Post
Popular Posts
- Knave Mini-Review, Hacks, Additions, and Other Resources
- Caverns of Thracia session log: February 2, 2019
- Hot Springs Island Mini-review After 6 sessions
- Recommended OSR Books
- Creating a Terse Key (and more) for Caverns of Thracia
- BB/X
- Improve your game with bits of OD&D
- Cleric Spells Are Herbs
- Universal Oldschool RPG Mechanic Toolkit
- Conditions
Topics
mechanics
(24)
GLOG
(9)
session report
(9)
Aid
(8)
class
(8)
setting
(8)
Caverns of Thracia
(7)
Kowloon Planet
(7)
bestiary
(7)
table
(7)
gm
(6)
Resource
(5)
duo
(5)
project
(4)
review
(4)
system
(4)
Fomalhaut
(3)
bbx
(3)
death and dismemberment
(3)
Hot Springs Island
(2)
Knave
(2)
faction
(2)
magic
(2)
npc
(2)
race
(2)
rules
(2)
spells
(2)
theory
(2)
toddler
(2)
200 Words
(1)
HSI
(1)
LotFP
(1)
Secret Santicore
(1)
Stargazer
(1)
adventure
(1)
advice
(1)
character sheet
(1)
cleric
(1)
curse
(1)
disease
(1)
dwarf
(1)
generator
(1)
herbs
(1)
humor
(1)
level
(1)
meta
(1)
random encounters
(1)
treasure
(1)
Related Blogs
-
The Mourning Mansion - By HilanderSelf PublishedOSRLevels 1-3 Sixty years ago, the young noble who built this mansion was to take a bride. Cakes were baked, a dress adorned with ...3 hours ago
-
-
Wikipedia Links Slushpile 2 - Slushpile index Second verse, same as the first; these are all links I saved for myself in my general notes doc. 1. Irish Bell Shrines Reliquaries for ...3 days ago
-
Under Gallax Hall - Level 4 - Monastery - *"I'm challenging myself to try and write at least 1-3 rooms per day to crank this thing out in like... 3 months, maybe?"* -Me, about 5 years ago. Been ...4 days ago
-
Transit - *Setting a Bearing*Before casting off, the ship must set its bearing to an agreed destination. This requires a meeting of the Bearing Council, which con...5 days ago
-
Best Books of 2025 - By tradition, December is marked on the 25th by Christmas Day, on the 24th by Christmas Eve, on the 26th by Boxing Day, on the 31st by New Year's Eve, an...5 days ago
-
d100 - Lair Locations - When Stocking Hexes, I occasionally find myself at a loss when it comes to all those “Lairs” that can get generated in the Process. Those Encounters/Mons...5 days ago
-
OSR: Treasure for Dungeon / Room Stocking - Dungeon stocking is tricky. Over and over, people ask "How much treasure should I include per room / dungeon level / PC?" The answer varies enormously be...2 weeks ago
-
Are Conservative Gamers Just Stupid? - There's been a recent one of those fistfight-in-a-fishbowl things online. A go-round of grousing lately online, dozens of responses. Conservative gamers...2 weeks ago
-
Bon Mots - The Seven Somethings of Evelyn Somebody - To generate your own trendy book title, roll d20 twice and combine: *1** The Seven Abbots of Evelyn Costello* *2* * The Seven Ampersands of...4 weeks ago
-
On Bounty, Questions worth asking. - Well? Will we? Available Now! https://sinlessrpg.com ------------------------------ *Hack & Slash* Follow, Twitch, Support, Donate to end Cancer (5 ...2 months ago
-
What is the point of the OSR? - Over on Reddit, Kaliburnus asks What the point of the OSR is? He concludes his post with some questions. So, honest question, what is the point of OSR?...2 months ago
-
Gormand's Larder is back - Hello, I made a 36 pages extended edition of my old zine Gormand's Larder. You get the digital version here: https://evlyn.itch.io/gormand-larder2 months ago
-
An Appendix N(VLG) - A few days / weeks / units of time ago I saw Prismatic Wasteland’s round-up of people’s appendix Ns. Well, thought I unto mine self, I have just such a one...2 months ago
-
Eyes of Idola, Part 2 - This is Part 2. Here is Part 1. *Concept 1: Entering the Dungeon* Descending the stairs into B1, the party reach rooms that are dark, crowded, flooded, a...3 months ago
-
Deep Space & Derelicts: Basic/Xenotech version, an idea for a game - here's a little idea for a game that's been floating around my head for a while. what if early D&D had been based around classic scifi rather than cl...6 months ago
-
Blogs on Tape season 6 has begun! - Hi everybody! Its been a minute. How are you? Everything is awful all the time? Horrors never cease? You’re being driven mad by the weight of the unfathoma...7 months ago
-
Chatbot and the Demiurge for Solo Play - I have been playing around with my solo protocols, the d6 demiurge ( https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/347048/the-d6-demiurge-protocols-for-solo-pl...8 months ago
-
Another Underclock - I've been using Arnold's Underclock since about 5 minutes after that blog post dropped. It's great! Trouble is I do miss the "oh shit there's something her...9 months ago
-
Articulations - Creating house rules, custom rules specific to a local group or campaign, has been common throughout the history of D&D. What makes an effective house rule...11 months ago
-
Notes on a semi-successful skill system - When I finished my Team Tsathogga campaign back in 2019, one of the things that I noted afterwards was the extent to which fighters had struggled to keep...3 years ago
-
As Useful As A Pile Of Dicks - Remember STEAL THE EYES OF YASHOGGHUH? Still working on it. The post As Useful As A Pile Of Dicks first appeared on Last Gasp.4 years ago
-
-
Spoils of the Gorgon Coast: The Degenerate Heir - As the kickstarter for the Zinequest Quartet winds down, I find myself in awe of the amount of folks who seem interested in my project; especially given t...5 years ago
-
Prinny Dood! - Prinnies are the souls of the dead who are working off their lives of sin either in the heavenly or infernal realms before they are able to reincarnate...5 years ago
-
Thursdays in Thracia – Part 21 - This is Part 21 of my Thursdays in Thracia B/X Dungeons & Dragons Campaign, an actual play of Jennell Jaquays’ The Caverns of Thracia. For more context, st...6 years ago
-
Elsai Overview - Elsai is a small planet and the only inhabited one orbiting its star. From its spaceport—nothing more than a flattened chunk of rock used by stellar scum—E...6 years ago
-
"The Gardens of Ynn" Referee Control Panels - I recently picked up Emmy Allen's excellent *The Gardens of Ynn*, and I think this will be the next adventure I run. I still have an itch for *Alice in Won...6 years ago
-
Goodbye and Good Luck - Well some of you may have noticed this blog has been down, restricting access for some time. For various reasons I've decided to step away from the OSR...7 years ago
-
Dolmenwood: d30 Encounter Tables - I wrote a few posts with ideas about Dolmenwood encounter tables ages ago. I wasn't really satisfied with those big d100 tables, though, so the topic which...8 years ago
The recent Oerth Journal #31 (e-zine for Greyhawk fans) features several articles on factions which may interest you if you're working on Thracia's factions: https://greyhawkonline.com/oerthjournal/
ReplyDeleteAllan.
Thanks, this is good stuff!
Delete